(Records through the 1963 season, McDonald's last season with Philadelphia)
• [1st] Most Touchdowns Receiving, Season – 13 (1960, 1961)
• [1st] Most Receptions, Season – 64 (1961)
• [1st] Most Yards Receiving, Game – 237 (vs. New York Giants, Dec. 10, 1961)
• [1st] Most Yards Receiving, Season – 1,146 (1962)
• [1st] Longest Punt Return – 81 yards (vs. New York Giants, Oct. 4, 1959)
• [Tied for 1st] Most TDs, Game – 4 (vs. New York Giants, Oct. 4, 1959 - 3 rec., 1 punt return)
• [Tied for 2nd] Most Receptions, Game – 11 (vs. St. Louis Cardinals, Oct. 15, 1961)
Rams' records held by McDonald
(Records through the 1966 season, McDonald's last season with Los Angeles)
• [Tied 3rd] Most Touchdown Receptions, Season – 9 (1965)
• [4th] Most Receptions, Season – 67 (1965)
Falcons' records held by McDonald
(Records through the 1967 season, McDonald's last season with Atlanta)
• [1st] Most Touchdown Receptions, Season – 4 (1967)
• [Tied 1st] Most Touchdowns, Game – 2 (vs. Minnesota Vikings, Oct. 29, 1967)
• [Tied 1st] Most Consecutive Games with a Reception – 12 (1967)
• [2nd] Longest Pass Reception – 75 yards (vs. Baltimore Colts, Nov. 12, 1967)
Note: McDonald did not set any team records as a member of the Cowboys or Browns.